A low-roof ranch with buff brick and pale siding beyond a deep autumn lawn, with a concrete walk and an ochre-leaved maple.

South Park Street's New Grocery Store Was Planned as a Backup. Now There Are Two.

"The city has tasked me with activating the corner and making sure that this is a hub," Kristie Maurer told the Cap Times shortly after her store opened. "I don't want to assume that my shoppers are just the people that live in this two-block radius."

Maurer's Urban Market opened Saturday, Oct. 10, at 801 Cedar St., on the corner of South Park and Cedar. The plans started years ago, when it looked like South Madison might lose its only full-service grocery store. That store, the Pick 'n Save across the street, is still open. So the new store went with a different plan: be a second stop on the corner, with counters and food the older store doesn't carry.

The store that was supposed to be insurance

The Pick 'n Save at 1312 S. Park St. has been a grocery store since the 1960s. It was a Copps for years and became a Pick 'n Save in 2017. Here is how the corner across the street went from a plan to a store, using the dates in the Cap Times account:

  1. 2018. The Pick 'n Save site was set to be torn down for a new clinic. A year later, SSM Health dropped the plan and built its clinic somewhere else.
  2. 2021. The city chose Milwaukee-based Rule Enterprises and the nonprofit Movin' Out to redevelop the former Truman Olson Army Reserve Center into a $42 million mixed-use project. The city also agreed to buy the grocery space for about $4.7 million.
  3. The first tenant. Luna's Groceries was lined up to run the store but pulled out before the city named Maurer's as the anchor.
  4. 2024. Design problems with the HVAC and refrigeration space caused repeated delays, and the City Council approved another $1 million for tenant improvements. Channel3000 reports that Maurer signed a 15-year lease with the city that year.
  5. October 2026. The store opened. The city owns the space, the lease includes renewal options, and the city's total investment is around $9 million.

District 13 Ald. Noah Lieberman wrote on his council blog before the opening that he had worked on the project for eight years, starting before he was elected in 2019. The space was planned as a safety net. It opened next to a grocery store that is still selling groceries.

Two stores of almost the same size, one crosswalk apart

The two stores are close in size, and their hours are close too.

Maurer's Urban Market Pick 'n Save
Address 801 Cedar St. 1312 S. Park St.
Size About 24,000 sq. ft. About 26,000 sq. ft.
Daily hours 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.
On this corner since October 2026 The 1960s

Maurer's sits on the ground floor of a building with 150 affordable apartments above it and 60 covered parking spaces. The store's website says to park behind the store. Pick 'n Save closes an hour later each night, so it is still the corner's late-night stop.

With two full stores of nearly the same size this close together, the new one had to give people a different reason to come in. That is how Maurer's was set up.

Built around the counters along the walls

Maurer told The Shelby Report that the counters along a store's outer walls, called the perimeter, are where independent grocers "really shine." Her store's perimeter has a lot packed into it:

  • A hot bar and a pizza program
  • A full-service deli supplied by the store's own kitchen, with meats and cheeses sliced to order next to a coffee counter
  • A Caribou Coffee counter
  • Sushi and a Picadeli salad bar
  • Meat and seafood counters
  • Beer, wine and spirits with an emphasis on local producers, plus 12 feet of nonalcoholic beer, wine and spirits

The middle aisles carry regular groceries alongside gluten-free, Asian, Hispanic, Indian and Mediterranean items. There is also a lot of cheese. "At some point I might have said I think this might be a cheese shop, not a grocery store," Maurer told The Shelby Report. She said she hopes to bring people in at lunch as well as for a full grocery run.

Her pricing explains a lot about the store. She told the Cap Times that she sees shoppers splitting their spending:

"In their shopping basket, they're going to spend money on something that they deem as a premium, whatever that is, sliced deli meat, rotisserie chickens, a fancy wine, and then where it's not as important to them, tortilla chips or cereal, or take your pick – it's not a big deal to them, they're going to save there."

She also talked about the size of the store. She wants it big enough that "you don't feel tight" pushing a cart and can do your whole shopping trip there, but not so big that the rent outruns the business. Because there is less floor space, the store carries fewer sizes of each product so it can offer more kinds of products. She also described a service built for neighbors who don't drive: shop, then have Maurer's deliver the groceries while you ride the bus or bike home.

That experience comes from her family. Her father, Jeff Maurer, has been a grocer for 50 years. The two of them opened his first store in 2010 on a university campus in downtown Madison, and later ran Maurer's Market in Wisconsin Dells together. She told The Shelby Report that she wants the new store to have a "we-know-everybody's-name type of vibe."

Lane's Kringle is back on a South Madison shelf

One bakery detail matters most this time of year. Lane's Bakery left South Madison when its ownership changed, and the new owners turned it into a wholesale bakery that only does occasional pop-ups. Maurer's carries Lane's Wisconsin Kringle and cakes in its bakery department, The Shelby Report says. If you need a Kringle for Thanksgiving dessert or a December office party, you can now find one at the corner of Park and Cedar instead of waiting for a pop-up.

The store also shows some local history. Crates on the seafood department wall honor the Lake Mendota Fish Company, Dairyland Dock and Oyster, and the Gilded Gill at the Union Marina. A huge painted crappie above the meat and seafood counters honors Kristie Maurer's grandfather, who loved to fish, as the Wisconsin State Journal reported.

The rest of the block this fall

Maurer said she wants the corner to be a hub, and several other places on this stretch of South Park Street opened this year.

Luna's Groceries. Luna's ended up on Park Street after all, just not in the Cedar Street space. Owner Mariam Nuñez opened a second location this year in the former Yue-Wah Oriental Foods space. Her first store is in the Allied-Dunn's Marsh neighborhood. Madison365 reports that about 300 people came to the Park Street grand opening, and that the store focuses on culturally familiar groceries and a place for neighbors to connect. The Madison365 article also explains how neighbors can support the store this fall.

Moom Thai. This grab-and-go Thai restaurant at 1017 S. Park St. opened in October, according to In Business Madison.

Sista's Chicken and Fish. After operating as a catering company, Sista's opened a brick-and-mortar location at 1129 S. Park St. earlier this year, as noted in Madison365's guide to Madison Black Restaurant Week 2026.

Park Lofts. At 1150 S. Park St., Park Lofts held its ribbon cutting Oct. 7. The building adds 44 affordable homes, and some of them are set aside for young people moving out of foster care.

Put together, you can now get takeout Thai, fried fish, sushi from the counter at Maurer's, a Kringle and a full grocery run on a few blocks of South Park Street, with a Pick 'n Save still open until 10 p.m. across the street.

At The Collective Wisconsin, we follow corners like Park and Cedar because a new anchor store changes the daily routine on every nearby block. If you live near South Park Street and want to know how this fall's openings fit into your home's story, start with our South Madison and Fitchburg neighborhood page, or request your free home valuation and we'll walk you through it.

Partner in Success

Whether it’s your very first or the one you’ve always dreamed of. We will work hard for you, listen carefully to your needs, and stay committed to finding the right home for you.