A walk from the Midvale Boulevard entrance to the tree on Sunday, Nov. 22 passes a Mediterranean counter, an Italian kitchen, a clothing store and an ice cream shop that weren't open a year ago. Three of them are the first location their company has opened in Madison, in Wisconsin or anywhere in the Midwest.
Across the center, storefronts that went dark have been coming back quickly, several of them as regional debuts. WMTV reported on Nov. 5 that Hilldale is nearly full after about a dozen openings in two years, mixing national brands that are new to the state with local businesses. Most shopping centers can't say that about their vacancies, and it explains why the Hilldale on the holiday walk this year looks different from the one a lot of Near West neighbors remember.
Here are the changes behind this season's lineup, in the order the new tenants arrived:
| Address | What was there | What's there now | Opened | The "first" |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 554 N. Midvale Blvd. | Gigi's Cupcakes, closed Sept. 2025 | Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream | April 1, 2026 | Local ice cream maker |
| 700 N. Midvale Blvd. | n/a | Reformation | May 16, 2026 | First Wisconsin store |
| 670 N. Midvale Blvd. | Amara, closed July 2024 | North Italia | Sept. 2, 2026 | First Midwest location |
| 750 N. Midvale Blvd. | n/a | CAVA | Set for Nov. 11, 2026 | First Madison location |
The Amara-to-North Italia handoff took the longest. The Italian space sat empty for about two years before North Italia opened there in early September. Gigi's to Chocolate Shoppe took about six months.
Reformation is a good example of how this works. WMTV announced in February that the sustainability-focused clothing brand would open its first Wisconsin store at 700 N. Midvale Blvd., and Hilldale held the grand opening on May 16. Hilldale lists dresses, denim, separates, outerwear, shoes and bags.
North Italia, a modern Italian scratch kitchen, is the national brand's first Midwest location. In WMTV's Hilldale roundup, general manager Ali Scherer described it as "elevated yet casual" service for game days, date nights and special occasions. He added that "a lot of times people say they haven't had anything just exactly like this just yet." Executive chef Catie Swimm told the station Hilldale is "a community that people seem to really cherish around here."
CAVA continues the trend this month. In Business Madison reported that the fast-casual Mediterranean chain set Wednesday, Nov. 11 as the official opening of its first Madison restaurant at 750 N. Midvale Blvd. It is the chain's second in Wisconsin, after Greenfield in suburban Milwaukee. The menu covers bowls, pitas, dips and dressings. The listed hours are 10:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily, with digital order pickup and delivery.
Some of the openings are local. Hilldale general manager Amanda Stiebens told WMTV that the property balances national retailers with local businesses. "Hilldale loves being a part of the Madison community and reflecting Madison on our property, so it's really special to see our businesses perform and welcome new neighbors," she said.
Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream opened at 554 N. Midvale Blvd. on April 1. Its opening-day event ran from noon until 8 p.m. or until the ice cream ran out.
The next local addition is a year away. Dumpling Haus closed in May after 15 years at Hilldale. Its storefront at 540 N. Midvale Blvd. is set to become Thai Nimman, from Thai Basil owners Krittaphol "Kris" Poticharoen and Tharika "Gamzy" Poticharoen. WMTV reported Nov. 5 that the name comes from Nimmanhaemin Road in Chiang Mai. The couple told the station that "Nimman represents energy, food, creativity and people coming together," and that Hilldale gives them "that same feeling here in Madison."
The announced menu includes Pad Thai, Golden Mango Seafood Curry and Yentafo Hot Pot, cooked by experienced chefs from Thailand. Plans call for dine-in, takeout and a full-service bar, and the restaurant is slated to open in 2027. Thai Basil will stay open.
The biggest vacancy is the old Great Dane Pub & Brewing Co. space. The brewpub closed its Hilldale location in November 2025, and WMTV reported this month that the space is still vacant. The space has now been dark for a full year.
Two more retailers are on the way:
The old theater space is turning into a home goods store, which follows the same pattern as the center's other vacancies.
The changes are easiest to see at the center's busiest event of the year. The holiday dates on Near West Madison's two main shopping streets fall on Nov. 22 and the first weekend of December:
Monroe Street has had its own new arrival this fall. The Cap Times reported that Waltzing Matilda's opened at 1923 Monroe St. on Oct. 22, serving breakfast and lunch with a full bar, and that its owners planned to add evening drinks and shareable plates by December. The same roundup noted that Barrett's Bagels, which started at the Monroe Street Farmers' Market, now has a permanent shop at 3742 Speedway Road. It's open Friday through Sunday until the bagels sell out.
Most people walk or drive in on Midvale Boulevard, which got a resurfacing and safety project this summer. The City of Madison scheduled the work from July 6 to Aug. 15, 2026. Its Sept. 24 project update said nearly everything between Mineral Point Road and University Avenue was done. The remaining work was two rapid-flashing pedestrian beacons, one at Hillcrest Drive and one at the Hilldale entrance. The city posts updates on that project page as the work wraps up.
Patty Elson, a Madison resident WMTV spoke with at the center, said it works as more than a place to shop. "When I come here, I see this as a gathering place," she said. "Families, people bring their dogs, they bring their computers, and they're sitting in tables and chairs here getting coffee." This year, that gathering place has a new Italian kitchen, a Mediterranean counter, a local ice cream shop, a first-in-Wisconsin clothing store and a Thai restaurant coming in 2027.
If you own a home near Hilldale and wonder how the changes along Midvale and University show up in what your house is worth, The Collective Wisconsin tracks Near West Madison block by block. Request your free home valuation and we'll walk you through it before the tree lighting.
Whether it’s your very first or the one you’ve always dreamed of. We will work hard for you, listen carefully to your needs, and stay committed to finding the right home for you.